I had a hunter harvest nice bull elk and give me $200, I throw it back at them and say thanks but no thanks.
I have to agree with you rramv10 that the above comment surprised me and is rather arrogant. Though I haven't been on a guided hunt, I have been on guided fishing trips and its typical for my husband and I to tip about $200-250 for 3-4 days of full time guiding. I always thought that was generous considering that anything guided is generally not cheap, and we have to save up quite some time to go on one of these "special" guided trips.
Fortunately no one has thrown our "tip" back in our faces. They were all gracious and seemingly appreciative. $200 bucks is not a drop in the bucket for most folks.