4 replies [Last post]
Joined: 01/04/2004
Posts: 4
Elk Bullet Choice


I would enjoy some input on what bullet I should reload for my .300 Winchester Magnum. I will be using it for elk hunting where shots could range from 50 to 350 yards. The gun seems to be rather picky. I have tried Partitions, A-frames, and Barnes X`s but none of them will group under 2.5 inches. The rifle seems to love 200 grain Sierra Game Kings, 180 Grain Hornady SST`s and Interlocks, and 180 grain Ballistic Tips, and 180 grain Speer Hot Cores.

I guess I would like to shoot the 200-grain Sierras, but worry they are not tough enough to hammer through a quartering elk.

Any thoughts or ideas would be appreciated.

Warmest Regards,


Location: Wisconsin
Joined: 12/08/2003
Posts: 134
Elk Bullet Choice

Dan, I would avoid the ballistic tip. The rest should work fine. Sierra's 200 grain and Speer's 180 grain HOT-COR are both loaded by Federal in 300 mag, and both are recommended loads for large heavy, game. Both Speer and Sierra make good bullets. The SST is supposed to hold together real well too. I think any of those three will work fine but I have doubts about the BT for elk.

bitmasher's picture
Location: Colorado
Joined: 02/27/2002
Posts: 2973
Elk Bullet Choice


I have used the Sierras, Noslers, and Hornadys on elk; 150 and 180 grain variety out of an 30-06. I've seen the noslers come apart in one or two elk. The jacket would seem to come apart with bits of lead (we called it shrapnel at the time). Kind of strange and occured about 10 years ago.

As for quartering shots and what the 200 Sierras will do. Quartering away is usually not much worse than a broadside shot. I personally try to stay away from quartering towards shots though. All that muscle, bone, and shoulder blade(s) gives me the heebee jeebees. So if your concerned, just don't take the shot, otherwise you should be fine. Good Luck!

Joined: 08/11/2003
Posts: 19
Elk Bullet Choice

I guess I would have to say whatever bullet you feel comfortable shooting that has plenty of knock down power. I also prefer the broadside shot compared to the quartering away shot but that is a decision that has to be made in a quick second.

bigracks's picture
Location: craig colorado
Joined: 07/15/2003
Posts: 38
Elk Bullet Choice

barnes x very good choice for elk

Related Forum Threads You Might Like

ThreadThread StarterRepliesLast Updated
Elk caliber and bullet question ?elkkill062108/04/2009 17:08 pm
Bullet PreferencesSNOWMAN0813609/05/2007 22:11 pm
Bullet of your choice10pointer1511/10/2005 17:46 pm
Goat bullet placementLazy TL809/27/2007 19:50 pm
Bullet choiceR. Smith3711/17/2010 05:20 am