Neither of those you mentioned.
I have killed 3 using Buck Stop Doe In Heat but I can't say for sure that it was the scent that brought the bucks in.
However I can say that I have actually had a small buck come in and make a small scrape at the bottom of my wife's ladder stand after she used almost a whole bottle of Code Blue Doe in Estrus.
I had a small buck come to the bottom of my stand to smell the Code Blue bottle that had fallen out of my pocket and landed on the ground. It was the same bottle that my wife had used and was almost 3 years old.
I am always amazed at the amount of scent control products that exist on the market today. But they are there for a reason. Game animals have incredible noses and if you go out into the field smelling like body odor, summer sausage, gasoline and last night's Miller High Life fiasco you will probably not be punching a tag. Scent control sprays aren't cheap though. On a college student budget I had a serious need to alleviate at least some of my hunting costs. This is why I decided to...