I just checked out thier site because I had never heard of them. To be fair they do ofer 60,000 acres of private free range hunts. Only 10,000 acres of the operation is high fence. It would just get confusing when telling your story since they do offer both types of hunts.
I've never been up to the Idaho ranch (I have their dvd showing both ranches and property) but the Utah ranch is 30 min from my house so I've been up around there quite a few times and it's a very good area and lots of elk. I don't know if you're wanting to do a high fence or free range hunt but the Utah ranch has more free range elk on private property than the Idaho ranch and with an almost 100% success rate on free range hunts in Utah I'd go with that. (Not 100% success rate because hunters don't find a bull "big" enough"
The Utah free range property has bulls hitting the 400" mark and possibly some bigger and tons of bulls in the 350+ range. The size of bull you are wanting to take all depends on how much $$$$ you are willing to pay them, so if you are wanting to pay the absolute minimum you can take a bull in the 300-320" . I'm not going to try and preach to you about how I feel on high fence hunts to free range hunts but if I were doing this hunt I'd do the free range hunt because it's still going to be a challenging, fun hunt and also more ethical and you will be seeing tons of bulls and you will take home your trophy.
Understand you will be hunting an animal that arrived on a simi a few days ago. Also, you can always upgrade - never downgrade. My recomendation is sign up for a management hunt and upgrade if you like - if you pay for a trophy and don't get it, you won't get a refund.
JimmyB's comments relate to the fenced hunting option. There is no guarantee on the free range hunt. I hinted with them in November.
Hunting is not usually a pursuit where instant gratification abounds. It takes a lot of time, practice, resources and patience to be a successful hunter. So when someone decides that an area they hunted only once without taking an animal is worthless and devoid of game, I don't quite understand it. These people usually jump from game management unit to game management unit; trying a new one every year.
Now don't get me wrong, there are people that just enjoy scouting and hunting...