7 replies [Last post]
Offline
Location: Nor Cal
Joined: 05/01/2009
Posts: 6
338 0r 300 win

I'm buying a new barrel for my Thompson Pro Hunter and I will useing this for elk hunting in Colorado. What do you all think 338 or the 300win? Help me make up my mind..

Bud
Offline
Location: Montana
Joined: 03/08/2009
Posts: 64
338 0r 300 win

hard to beat a 338 it is one of the best in my opinion. but you just asked a question that gets lots af guys fighting mad if their favorite caliber don't get picked. I'm sure you'll get lots of opinions. Argue

Offline
Moderator
Location: Nova Scotia
Joined: 08/17/2002
Posts: 1762
338 0r 300 win

What other calibers do you already have. If you have a 30 cal.(or close to it) I'd go with the .338 as well.

Offline
Location: Nor Cal
Joined: 05/01/2009
Posts: 6
338 0r 300 win

I have 270 wsm 30-06 and a 243. The 243 is theThompon and I just love this gun it is a real tack driver. I bought the Thompson for hunt the small deer out here in Calif and now that is all I want to use that is why the new barrel. I know I might get some people fighting I just don;t know much about the 338 execpt last year I hunted in Montana and the person we were on his ranch he had just got a new Rem 338 for is birthday and it did the job on a big 6X6 just folded these big bull. VERY IMPRESIVE

Offline
Location: Summit, IL
Joined: 10/22/2006
Posts: 706
338 0r 300 win

Everyone I know that has the 338 fed is MORE than happy with this round. Of course ALL weapons shoot a little different but all my Thompson barrels so far are tack drivers. I dont think I have yet to hear a complaint on the 338 fed. As long as you can handle the recoil I dont see you complaining about it either. It is more than sufficiant to harvest the largest of North American big game and from what I have heard a very accurate round as well. Flat shooting (for its size) with plenty of energy downrange. I personally havnt gotten one since I really dont need it. I primarily bowhunt these days and on the rare occation that I rifle hunt my yardages are rarely more than 200 yards so either my .444 or 30.06 or .270 or 7mm.08 or .303 do the job for me. Last thing I need is yet another choice sad (so my wife says) eye roll My own personal opinion is for the 338fed. based on opinions of people I personally know and trust their opinion of the calibre. Sigh, soon as me wife see's this she's gonna go on the warpath thinkin im going to get one for maself Yes may do it just to piss her off neener!

possum's picture
Offline
Location: SK Canada
Joined: 03/31/2009
Posts: 219
338 0r 300 win

I have shot a 338 win mag for the last 20+ years, i also have other calibers but when it comes to elk or moose i can tell you they work very well. If you handload you can get bullets from 160 gr to 300gr so it is good for anything from gophers to grizz . Recoil from a 300 win mag is worse than a 338 win mag in my opinion . Good luck in your quest for a new barrel but you cant go wrong with a 338 for elk, make sure to use a premium bullet too.

bitmasher's picture
Offline
Moderator
Location: Colorado
Joined: 02/27/2002
Posts: 2973
338 0r 300 win

Either would be fine as far as stopping power on elk. I would look at bullet weight, if you don't intend to shoot larger than 180gr, stick with the 300 win.

If you want to drive a 225gr bullet or higher, go with the 338.

Offline
Location: mississippi
Joined: 06/08/2009
Posts: 1
338 0r 300 win

gotta stick up for the 300...i hav had mine for a numer of years now and the gun shoots amazing. I use 180 grain and i get a nice flight path. My 300 is by far the gun i go to if i want the for sure shot.